Tramel: OKC Thunder lost a good coach in Billy Donovan, but 'it's no one's fault' that this era ends
Bad news for Oklahoma City basketball: the Thunder lost a good coach.
Good news for OKC basketball: the Thunder didn’t lose a great coach.
Just don’t go celebrating that reality. There aren’t a ton of great coaches walking Planet NBA, which is why Billy Donovan soon could resurface in Philadelphia or Chicago or an NBA port in need of a skipper.
Here you go. Donovan’s winning percentage of .608 ranks 11th all-time among coaches with at least five years of NBA experience. That’s out of 124 coaches.
I assume that makes you feel a little worse, and I assume you realize the next guy will have no chance of approaching that kind of winning.
Donovan’s departure, announced Tuesday night by the Thunder, came after his five-year contract expired and Sam Presti was unable to provide a road map for future success.
Kevin Durant, Russell Westbrook, Serge Ibaka, Victor Oladipo, Carmelo Anthony, Paul George, Chris Paul, Shai Gilgeous-Alexander. Donovan coached them all in his five Thunder seasons.
But the spigot of stars soon could close. Maybe this off-season, maybe next off-season, maybe mid-season, whenever that is. The Thunder soon could be headed for a tank job near you. Donovan, 55 and, just like the rest of us Oklahomans, in no mood for a rebuild, decided two in the bush trumped a bird in the hand.
- Related to this story
- Article: OKC Thunder: Seven takeaways from Game 7 loss to Rockets
- Article: Tramel: Lu Dort makes the grade, but OKC Thunder report card has some failures in Game 7 loss to Rockets
- Article: How James Harden and Rockets denied OKC Thunder despite an off night offensively: 'Never let a hard time humble us'
- Article: Carlson: Chris Paul and OKC Thunder 'fought hard all year' but suffer cruel fate in Game 7 loss to Rockets
- Article: OKC Thunder: Lu Dort, despite crushing turnover, shines in Game 7 loss to Rockets
- Article: Tramel: OKC Thunder's bizarro season ends with bizarro Game 7 but also with renewed hope for future
- Article: OKC Thunder: Five big questions heading into the offseason
- Article: OKC Thunder: Dennis Schröder finishes second for Sixth Man of the Year
- Article: Carlson: Why Thunder coach Billy Donovan has a big question to answer before new contract
- Article: OKC Thunder's Billy Donovan has been on winning and losing ends of 3-point revolution from Providence Friars to Houston Rockets
- Article: OKC Thunder: Billy Donovan won't return as coach next season
- Article: OKC Thunder timeline in Billy Donovan era
- Article: Carlson: Why OKC Thunder's track record with Billy Donovan, Scott Brooks could help Sam Presti in coaching search
- Article: OKC Thunder: 50 candidates to replace Billy Donovan as coach
- Article: Report: Thunder offered Billy Donovan contract prior to restart
- Article: Former Thunder coach Billy Donovan named new Chicago Bulls coach
- Article: Why did Donovan choose Chicago over Oklahoma City?
- Article: For former OKC Thunder coach Billy Donovan, job with Chicago Bulls 'came out of left field'
- Article: Tramel: Why Doc Rivers' firing with LA Clippers could help OKC Thunder
- Video: Thunder Update: Presti address Donovan's departure
- Video: OKC Thunder - Chris Paul animation
- Video: Thunder Update: Paul addresses delay of game call
- Video: Thunder Update: Thunder ends playoff run in Game 7 loss
- Video: Thunder Update: Life in the Bubble
“Sometimes the arc of things just don’t align,” Presti said. “It’s no one’s fault.”
Will Donovan be attractive on the coaching market? Probably. He’s got experience with winning teams. He’s got good communication skills and had zero problems with players, other than Durant’s occasional social-media nonsense to justify his Golden State decision. Donovan is a company man, which by coincidence is attractive to companies.
Donovan’s work in two precarious seasons — the first year without Durant and the first year without Westbrook — was superb. The Thunder won a ton of close games and overachieved.
Donovan’s work when Westbrook and George were tag-team partners was pedestrian. Win totals of 48 and 49, followed by first-round playoff eliminations.
Therein lies Donovan’s chief shortfall. A lack of playoff success. The Thunder has lost five straight playoff series. If Game 6 doesn’t happen — if Andre Roberson hadn’t found foul trouble, allowing Klay Thompson to go crazy, or if Westbrook and Durant hadn’t picked the worst time to play their worst — maybe there’s an NBA championship banner flying in Chesapeake Arena and Donovan is an Oklahoma hero on the level of Rodgers and Hammerstein.
But Game 6 did happen, and the Thunder hasn’t won a playoff series since.
Donovan’s “tactical competency,” the term Presti used upon Donovan’s hiring, was hit-and-miss, which frankly is the NBA standard. Tactics are overrated when Westbrook is your point guard. You go as he goes, and he goes at warp speed with little regard to schemes.
Donovan’s final two teams, plus the 2016-17 Westbrook-as-lone-soldier team, were far better defensively than offensively, which might surprise the masses. Donovan’s only elite offensive team was the Durant team of 2015-16. Easy to have a good offense when Kevin Durant is on your roster.
But Donovan gave young players room to grow. Lu Dort and Darius Bazley of recent vintage, but Roberson, Domantas Sabonis and Jerami Grant, too. That’s an underrated element of coaching.
Donovan didn’t really connect with Oklahomans, not the way Scotty Brooks or even Byron Scott did in Hornet days. But who cares? No one comes to the arena to see Mike Budenholzer or Frank Vogel coach.
“He did a great job for us and we have the utmost respect for him,” Presti said of Donovan. “The things he did will be remembered for a very long time.”
The first part is true. The second part is not. In the NBA, coaches rarely are difference-makers. Donovan was not.
The Thunder played hard for and rarely quit on Donovan, who generally had the ears of his players. Can’t ask for much more. There’s only one Gregg Popovich.
And now Donovan is gone. A good coach in a league that produces few great coaches.
Berry Tramel: Berry can be reached at 405-760-8080 or at firstname.lastname@example.org. He can be heard Monday through Friday from 4:40-5:20 p.m. on The Sports Animal radio network, including FM-98.1. You can also view his personality page at oklahoman.com/berrytramel.